In this paper, the author for the purposes of comparative analysis of the accuracy of
quantitative methods for assessing the security of wireless security systems, developed a
generalized computational method for comparing the accuracy of quantitative assessments of
the security of wireless security systems on the example of fire alarm systems. For this purpose,
the known security assessments of wireless security systems are described. The numerical
indicators of security assessments of the known technologies of protection of the radio channel
of fire alarm systems from unauthorized by two security assessments are presented. The known
approaches of the comparative analysis of the accuracy of quantitative estimates of protection
are shown, their shortcomings are specified. As a perspective approach of the comparative
analysis of the accuracy of quantitative estimates of security, free from the shortcomings of
known approaches, the apparatus of mathematical statistics is indicated. The application of
mathematical statistics to the comparative analysis of the accuracy of quantitative estimates of
security of wireless security systems is shown. The developed generalized computational
method of comparison of the accuracy of quantitative estimates of security of wireless security
systems is described. Its advantages over known methods, as well as its limitations are
indicated. Recommendations on its application to the comparative analysis of the accuracy of
quantitative security assessments are given. It is also indicated that the developed
computational method is generalized – its potential can be used for comparative evaluation of
the same type of quantitative security assessments of a wide class of wireless security systems
for the purposes of determining which of the security assessments has greater accuracy of
security.
1. Zhitnikov V.P. Ocenka dostovernosti chislennyh rezul'tatov pri nalichii
neskol'kih metodov resheniya zadachi / V.P. Zhitnikov, N.M. Sheryhalina.
Vychislitel'nye tekhnologii. 1999. v. 4. no. 6. pp. 77-87 (In Russian).
2. Koryachko V.P. Teoreticheskie osnovy SAPR: ucheb. dlya vuzov / V.P.
Koryachko, V.M. Kurejchik, I.P. Norenkov. M.: Energoatomizdat Publ., 1987.
400 p. (in Russian).
3. Polyanskij D.A. Ocenka zashchishchennosti / D.A. Polyanskij. Vladimir:
Vladim. gos. un-ta Publ., 2005. 80 p. (In Russian).
4. Zhuk A.P. Metodika ocenki zashchishchennosti besprovodnoj signalizacii s
povyshennoj tochnost'yu / A.P. Zhuk, A.A. Gavrishev.
Infokommunikacionnye tekhnologii. 2018. v. 16. no 1. pp.116-122. (In
Russian).
5. Gavrishev A.A. Sravnitel'nyj analiz metodik ocenki zashchishchennosti
besprovodnyh ohranno-pozharnyh signalizacij / A.A. Gavrishev, A.P. Zhuk,
D.L. Osipov. Prikladnaya informatika. 2018. v. 13. no 2 (74). pp. 98-108 (in
Russian).
6. Gavrishev A.A. Ocenka zashchishchennosti besprovodnoj signalizacii ot
nesankcionirovannogo dostupa na osnove ponyatij nechetkoj logiki / A.A.
Gavrishev, V.A. Burmistrov, D.L. Osipov. Prikladnaya informatika. 2015. v.
10. no. 4(58). pp. 62–69 (In Russian).
7. Gavrishev A.A. Analiz tekhnologij zashchity radiokanala ohranno-pozharnyh
signalizacij ot nesankcionirovannogo dostupa / A.A. Gavrishev, A.P. Zhuk,
D.L. Osipov. Trudy SPIIRAN. 2016. no. 4 (47). pp. 28–45 (In Russian).
8. Zhuk A.P. Ocenka zashchishchyonnosti besprovodnoj signalizacii ot
nesankcionirovannogo dostupa na osnove matricy nechyotkih pravil / A.P.
Zhuk, A.A. Gavrishev, D.L. Osipov. Matematicheskie struktury i
modelirovanie. 2016. no. 1(37). pp. 112-120 (In Russian).
Gavrishev Alexey Andreevich
Email: alexxx.2008@inbox.ru
FSAEI HE "North-Caucasus Federal Universit"
Stavropol, Russian Federation
