Сравнение точности аппроксимации экспериментальных данных методом наименьших относительных квадратов с методом наименьших квадратов
Работая с нашим сайтом, вы даете свое согласие на использование файлов cookie. Это необходимо для нормального функционирования сайта, показа целевой рекламы и анализа трафика. Статистика использования сайта отправляется в «Яндекс» и «Google»
Научный журнал Моделирование, оптимизация и информационные технологииThe scientific journal Modeling, Optimization and Information Technology
Online media
issn 2310-6018

Comparison of the accuracy of experimental data approximation using the least relative squares method with the least squares method

idGolovanchikov A.B. idDoan C.M. idPetrukhin A.V. idMerentsov N.A.

UDC 678.04
DOI: 10.26102/2310-6018/2020.28.1.042

  • Abstract
  • List of references
  • About authors

The results of comparing the accuracy of approximation of experimental or tabular data obtained using the standard method of least squares (LSM) and the proposed method of least relative squares (LRSM), for example, a given table dependence of the viscosity of a water-glycerine solution on the mass concentration of glycerol. The advantage of the latter is shown as the sum and average values of the local relative deviation of calculated data of viscosity of the desired solution obtained by LRSM, with similar data obtained by standard LSM and maximum values of these relative deviations. So, calculated using LSM average relative deviations of theoretical viscosity of an aqueous solution of glycerin from the specified table, in absolute value equal to 12.9%; LRSM of 5.8%, i.e., below 2 times. Accordingly the largest relative deviations in the LSM are 17.9%, and LRSM – 10.6 %, that is, reduced by 68%. It is proposed to determine the conditional values of parallel experiments based on the experimental data of the main experiment. To do this, the calculation of conditional numerical values of the i-th parallel experience is determined by the method of piecewise linear approximation of i-1 and i+1 numerical values of the main experience or table data. A correlation analysis is performed to determine the correlation coefficients, reproducibility, adequacy, and significance of the coefficients of the resulting regression equation.

1. Bondar A. G. Planning an experiment in the chemical industry (Main provisions, examples and tasks) . Bondar A. G., Statyukha G. A.-Kiev: Vyshcha SHKOLA, 1976. and technological processesMoscow: Chemistry, 1973.

2. Zakheim A. Yu. Introduction to modeling of chemical and technological processesMoscow: Chemistry, 1973.

3. Golovanchikov A. B., Tyabin N. V. Method of interpolating experimental data in determining the rheological properties of liquids .– Engineering and physical journal, 1981; XLI (1):70-73.

4. Brief reference of physical and chemical quantities . edited by Ravdel A. A. and Ponomareva A. M.-L.: Chemistry, 1983.

5. Golovanchikov A. B., Doan min Kyong, Dulkin T. A. SVID. about the state registration of the computer program No. 2018613318 of March 7, 2018, the Russian Federation. Program for calculating the parameters of a linear equation using the method of least relative squares. Volgstu. - 2018.

6. Akhnazarova S. L., Kafarov V. V.-Optimization of experiment in chemistry and chemical industry . M.: Higher school, 1978.

7. Golovanchikov A. B., Doan Minh Quang, T. A. Dulkin. SVID. about the state registration of the computer program No. 2018613321 of March 7, 2018, the Russian Federation. The program for the calculation of the criteria of the regression analysis linear equation . VSTU. - 2018.

8. Golovanchikov A. B., Doan min Kyong, Shibitova N. V. Approximation of experimental data using the least squares method and the least relative squares method . Energy and resource saving: industry and transport. 2019;26(1):42-44.

Golovanchikov Alexander Borisovich
Doctor of Technical Sciences, Professor
Email: pahp@vstu.ru

ORCID |

Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education "Volgograd State Technical University"

Volgograd, Russian Federation

Doan Cuong Min

Email: victorydoan@yandex.ru

ORCID |

Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education "Volgograd State Technical University"

Volgograd, Russian Federation

Petrukhin Alexey Vladimirovich
Candidate of Technical Sciences, Associate Professor
Email: cad@vstu.ru

ORCID |

Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education "Volgograd State Technical University"

Volgograd, Russian Federation

Merentsov Nykolay Anatolevich
Candidate of Technical Sciences, Associate Professor
Email: pahp@vstu.ru

ORCID |

Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education "Volgograd State Technical University"

Volgograd, Russian Federation

Keywords: linearization, approximation, absolute and relative deviations, lsm and lrsm, correlation coefficient, reproducibility, adequacy

For citation: Golovanchikov A.B. Doan C.M. Petrukhin A.V. Merentsov N.A. Comparison of the accuracy of experimental data approximation using the least relative squares method with the least squares method. Modeling, Optimization and Information Technology. 2020;8(1). Available from: https://moit.vivt.ru/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/GolovanchikovSoavtors_1_20_2.pdf DOI: 10.26102/2310-6018/2020.28.1.042 (In Russ).

603

Full text in PDF